Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Credit & Debit Card Processors Are Losing Your Data But May Not Be Liable For Your Personal Losses


While it is unlikely you have ever heard of Heartland Payment Systems or RBS WorldPay or any other of the dozens of networks your credit and debit card transactions travel through to process your morning latte purchase, hackers are all too aware of these treasure chests. Processors are likely to be the top targets for mass data compromise and identity theft in the coming years yet surprisingly, these back office firms may not be responsible for your losses.

According to Ronald Mann, a professor and co-chairman of the Charles E. Gerber Transactional Studies Program at Columbia Law School, payment processors that experience data losses may be protected against class action lawsuits if they can prove PCI compliance. This may be the case with the massive Heartland Payment Systems breach, which may have lost data on over 100 million transactions. Stop to think about the size of this breach – it roughly equates to a transaction a person for 1/3 of the US population!

There have already been three class action lawsuits filed against Heartland, but Mann says it would be very difficult for plaintiffs to prove negligence since Heartland should be able to prove it met the industry’s PCI (Payment Card Industry) standard. PCI is arguably ineffective at stopping, let alone detecting today’s sophisticated cyber attacks. Avivah Litan, distinguished analyst at Gartner, recently said that card processors are more vulnerable to attacks because while payment industry rules dictate that credit card data is encrypted while being stored at retailers, processors and banks it does not have to be encrypted while being transferred on private networks. While banks and retailers can also communicate on private networks, the attacks against processors is a much newer phenomenon and can produce the biggest number of transactions since processors by nature are consolidating activities across many retailers and banks.

Take for example, a simplified card transaction: You go to your favorite coffee shop and order a latte. You swipe a credit, debit or gift card at the register. In sub-second speed the transaction goes from the retailer to the processor, to your bank to check funds and to the retailer to approve the purchase. Once approved, the processor queues your transaction in a batch process to transfer the funds from your bank account to the retailer’s bank account, usually within 24 hours.

There are dozens of major processors across the US that handle transactions from millions of vendors and banks. Processors are a major hub of the system and are therefore a lucrative target for fraudsters. Currently if a processor complies with the PCI standard, which is clearly not tight enough to protect all network vulnerabilities, that processor should not be held accountable for current and future fraud against compromised accounts. In most cases the card issuer or banks protect the consumer, but always. Debit and gift cards shift some or all liability to the consumer and any future fraud perpetrated against an individual on different account may be hard to tie back to one particular data loss event, especially since processors and banks will not generally tell you when your information has been compromised!

So what’s the moral of the story – even if you are very careful with your own information, your identity can still be stolen. Protect yourself where you can, and be cognizant of all public data breaches.

(The following were sourced for this article: Defense Seen for Heartland vs. Suits; Cardline; February 10, 2009 and Credit Card Hackers Find New, Rich Targets; MSNBC; Bob Sullivan; January 23, 2009)

Friday, February 6, 2009

“People really hate you, and they are starting to hate us just for hanging out with you”


House Financial Services Committee Chairman Barney Frank this week outlined his plan for financial reform. While his plan was, as we may have expected, a little vague and non-committal, he did make a comment that clearly shows his concern about his own public perception and re-electability. He said he has been telling bankers:

"Here's the problem: People really hate you, and they are starting to hate us just for hanging out with you. And you have to help us deal with it. You have to avoid being stupid."

Hey Barney, not only will the American public continue to think you are a nimrod for your part in the financial crisis and delayed response with the first bail-out package, now the bankers are going to hate you too for calling them stupid.

(Quote sourced from American Banker, Fed First as Hill Tackles Reg Reform in 2 Parts, Feb 4, 2009)

Monday, November 24, 2008

Unemployed IT Workers to Drive Increase in Fraud

That is the hypothesis Avivah Litan, security analyst at Gartner proposes in a November Forbes article. She said that “in recent months, banking clients have been warning her of a spike in fraud, much of it based on the use of stolen financial data. There's been a marked increase in the number of attacks and the number of successful fraud attempts.”

Litan cites the growing pool of unemployed IT workers as a major fraud catalyst because they possess the “technical abilities needed to steal data or perpetrate fraud” and intimate knowledge of former employers’ IT systems.

Desperation often pushes regularly rule-abiding people into taking risks they wouldn’t in normal circumstances. "In times like these, people need the cash," says Litan. I am afraid she has identified yet another serious threat to the financial system and your bank account in the coming months.

Tuesday, May 6, 2008

Words of Wisdom from Omaha's Oracle


"Capitalism without failure is like Christianity without hell" - said Warren Buffet from Berkshire's annnual shareholders meeting this week.

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Somber Demographic and Spending Trends Poised to Create Major Headache for Next President

Washington Post Columnist Robert Samuelson today outlined the demographical and economic trends behind the current slow down of consumer spending. While we are all familiar with the current credit crunch, he also points out that natural “life cycle” spending will also contribute to a consumer slow down as the US population continues to age.

This is a very somber but important insight as people borrow and spend more in their 30s and 40s and slow in their 50s and 60s as they borrow less and incomes decline.

As you can see in the chart based on US Census Bureau data, a substantial percentage of the US population will be in the 50+ ranges moving forward. Real estate and investment income can prop up incomes and increase spending as it has for much of the last decade, but the likelihood of that happening in the next two to five years is slim. I would assume that wealthy older Americans should have conservatively constructed portfolios in the current trough and housing doesn’t look to recover anytime soon either. For an even gloomier look into our economic future, look at where AARP says older American’s income comes from as of 2004 – Social Security…

So what does this mean for politics? Samuelson goes on to say that “The ebbing shopping spree may challenge the next president in ways that none of the candidates has yet contemplated.” While all candidates may have contemplated a slow start to their term, have they dreamt about what it will feel like to bear the brunt of public frustration in a long-term recession? This sets the stage for a likely four and out scenario.

(charts from wallstreetexaminer.com/blogs/winter/?p=362)